The 2024 Toy Hall of Fame finalists have been announced, and this year’s lineup includes some of the most iconic toys and games that have shaped generations. From classic collectibles to enduring interactive games, each nominee brings its unique legacy to the table. In this article, we’ll explore each finalist, ranking them by their impact on culture and play, and predict which three toys are likely to earn their place in the Hall of Fame. Read on to discover our top picks and personal insights into why these toys are so deserving of this year’s honor.
Go here to see the 2024 finalists
12. Sequence
Created in the 1980s, Sequence is a strategic game combining cards and board play. Players use a deck of cards to place chips on a board, aiming to create a five-chip sequence. This unique blend of luck and strategy has made it popular for game nights.
Analysis: Sequence is a fun mix of cards and board play, ideal for game nights. Although popular, it hasn’t yet reached the iconic status of other nominees. It might need more time to become Hall of Fame-worthy.
11. Phase 10
Phase 10, a rummy-style card game created by Kenneth R. Johnson in 1982, challenges players to complete ten unique sets or “phases.” Known for its accessibility, Phase 10 has become a family game enjoyed across generations.
Analysis: Phase 10 is a family favorite that’s easy to learn and entertaining. However, it lacks the historical impact and nostalgia of other finalists. While popular, it’s not quite top-tier for 2024.
10. Stick Horse (Hobbyhorse)
The stick horse, or hobbyhorse, is a classic toy with centuries-old roots, encouraging imaginative play. Traditionally made from a wooden stick with a horse head, it has allowed children to pretend they’re riding horses, sparking creativity for generations.
Analysis: The stick horse represents timeless imaginative play, but it feels like a relic of its era. Without the lasting cultural influence seen in other nominees, it’s unlikely to make the cut this year, though it deserves recognition.
9. Choose Your Own Adventure Gamebooks
Emerging in the late 1970s, Choose Your Own Adventure books allowed readers to steer their story paths with interactive choices. Created by Edward Packard and later published by Bantam Books, these books introduced interactive storytelling, laying the groundwork for role-playing games.
Analysis: These books gave kids control over stories and inspired the interactive storytelling found in games today. Despite their influence, their popularity has faded, so they might not be a top choice this year compared to more enduring toys.
8. Apples to Apples
Released in 1999, Apples to Apples is a social game where players match nouns to adjectives, often creating hilarious combinations. Created by Matt Kirby, the game quickly became a favorite for its easy play and humor, making it a party staple.
Analysis: Apples to Apples bridges age gaps with humor and creativity, making it a great party game. However, it doesn’t quite have the deep nostalgia of other contenders. While it’s worthy of nomination, it’s likely not a top-three inductee this year.
7. Remote-Controlled (R/C) Vehicles
Popularized in the 1960s and 70s, R/C vehicles let users control cars, planes, and boats via radio waves. With roots in early aviation toys, R/C vehicles continue to captivate enthusiasts and inspire interest in mechanics and engineering.
Analysis: R/C vehicles offer skill-building and fun for all ages. Yet, without a defining brand, this broad category may struggle in the Hall of Fame selection. It’s iconic, but this year may not be its time.
6. Trampoline
First patented in 1945 by George Nissen and Larry Griswold, the trampoline was initially designed for gymnastics. Its entry into backyards brought endless active fun, making it a staple of outdoor play and fitness.
Analysis: The trampoline is a backyard classic providing fun and exercise, though it’s also known for injuries. Its universal appeal may eventually earn it a Hall of Fame spot, but it’s not a top pick for this year.
5. My Little Pony
Hasbro introduced My Little Pony in 1983. With colorful ponies, brushable manes, and unique personalities, the line quickly became a hit with children. Over time, it expanded into TV shows and movies, promoting themes of friendship across generations.
Analysis: My Little Pony combines imaginative play with friendship themes. Although its popularity has fluctuated, a devoted fanbase has kept it relevant. This adaptability earns it a mid-level ranking for 2024.
4. Balloons
Balloons have been used for centuries, from animal bladders to modern latex designs. Widely available since the early 20th century, they’re now integral to celebrations, decorations, and games, bringing color and joy to events.
Analysis: Balloons add fun to any event, making them essential for celebrations. However, they feel more like accessories to play with than toys themselves, making them a unique but unlikely pick for this year.
3. Hess Toy Trucks
Since 1964, Hess Toy Trucks have been a holiday staple, with each year featuring a new model. Known for their durability and collectible quality, these trucks became family traditions, with children eagerly awaiting the latest model each Christmas.
Analysis: A holiday staple and collectible favorite, Hess Toy Trucks holds a special place in toy history. Their quality and nostalgic value make them my underdog pick for this year, deserving of recognition for their role in holiday traditions.
2. Pokémon Trading Card Game
Launched in 1996, the Pokémon TCG built on the franchise’s popularity, allowing fans to collect and battle Pokémon. This card game became a playground staple worldwide, influencing the trading card genre and appealing to collectors and players alike.
Analysis: Pokémon TCG has shaped generations, creating a global community of collectors and players. Much like Magic: The Gathering (already inducted), Pokémon is more than a card game—it’s a cultural phenomenon. Its impact and ongoing popularity make it a prime candidate for induction.
1. Transformers
Created by Hasbro and Takara in 1984, Transformers toys are “robots in disguise,” converting between robots and vehicles. Inspired by Japanese toy lines, Transformers became an icon of the 80s and 90s, expanding into comics, TV shows, and films, captivating fans across generations.
Analysis: Transformers is my top pick for the Hall of Fame. Its unique robot-to-vehicle concept captivated kids in the 80s and 90s and continues to inspire. With its movies, toys, and iconic brand status, Transformers remains an enduring symbol of creativity and storytelling, making it the perfect choice for induction in 2024.
Final Picks for 2024 Induction
For my top three picks, Transformers, Pokémon Trading Card Game, and Hess Toy Trucks stand out as the strongest candidates. Transformers and Pokémon TCG both have legendary, multi-generational fanbases and cultural influence, while Hess Toy Trucks bring a unique holiday tradition and enduring quality. While all the finalists have their merits, these three offer a blend of nostalgia, creativity, and cultural relevance that would make them perfect 2024 inductees.
